The Ethical Dilemma of E-Cigarette Regulation - 1923 Words

Introduction Ethical dilemmas occur on many different scales. These dilemmas, and the complexity attached to them, range from personal to corporate conflict. Depending on the nature and structure of a particular situation and the values in conflict, personal definitions of what an ethical dilemma is may vary. Harold Gortner defines an ethical dilemma as â€Å" a situation where two or more competing values are important and in conflict. If you serve one value, you cannot server another, or you must deny of disserve one or more values in order to maintain one or more of the others†. Identified in this paper is an ethical dilemma anchored in the â€Å"Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act† signed into law by President Obama in 2009. This†¦show more content†¦In September the numbers showed that the percentage of middle school and high school students who have tried e-cigs doubled from 3.3% in 2011 to 6.8% in 2012. Tobacco companies have bought out small e-cig manufactories in efforts to mitigate the decline in conventional cigarette sells as a result of strict regulation. Unregulated, e-cigs allow tobacco companies to advertise and market to youth in ways that the FDA has prohibited tobacco companies to advertise conventional cigarettes. The lack of information and research regarding the content and long-term benefits or harms of e-cigs present uncertainty and ambiguity when trying to determine if e-cigs should be deemed a tobacco product and regulated as such. The loophole in The Tobacco Control Act-An Ethical Analysis Before attempting to analyze the dilemma, elaboration of the ethical dilemma and the actors involved is necessary. The ethical problem attached to the Tobacco Control Act and the regulation of e-cigs is that the policy allows the Center for Tobacco product to regulate based on science and facts. However, e-cigs are quickly growing in popularity while scientific studies are slowly completed and data about the long term health affects is slowly gathered. There is no concrete understanding of what the health implications are from smoking e-cigs. There is also no agreement between the tobacco companies, health advocates and FDA on the benefits orShow MoreRelatedThe Ethical Concerns Involving Tobacco1680 Words   |  7 PagesThe main ethical concerns involving tobacco is well known to educated Americans; however, the ethics around the marketing aspects of tobacco, especially tobacco exposure to children, are less talked about. Some of the early marketing decisions of tobacco can be trac ed back to one of the most renowned and valuable cigarette brands in the world, Marlboro. Marlboro first emerged onto the tobacco scene at the beginning of the nineteenth century. They originally were a cigarette brand with a female-basedRead MoreBusiness Law Midterm1264 Words   |  6 Pages(Department) prohibition of the sale of e-cigarettes in the U.S. was constitutional. A law is unconstitutional if it violates the 5th amendment (procedural due process and substantive due process) and/or the 14th Amendment (equal protection). The Department could argue that the prohibition should be upheld since it is rationally related to a legitimate goal under minimal scrutiny (14th amendment). Since e-cigarettes closely resemble tobacco cigarettes that have already been proven to resultRead MoreThe Food And Drug Administration Is A Regulatory Agency Responsible For The Public Health Of American Residents Essay1800 Words   |  8 PagesThe Food and Drug Administration is a regulatory agency responsible for the public health of American residents. The agency is located in Silver Springs, Maryland. The current extent of FDA regulations reaches a wide variety of product groups such as electronic devices, cosmetics, foods, biologics, tobacco, medical devices, and veterinary devices (US Food Drug Administration, 2016). The FDA is also accountable for the safety of the food supply, prescription drugs, and the manufacturing of productsRead MoreResearch Project On Smoking Tobacco Cigarettes3740 Words   |  15 PagesIntro duction Smoking tobacco cigarettes has been recognized as the leading cause of lung cancer and other health related illnesses in the developed world. But there is a new emergence of electronic cigarettes, which can deliver nicotine without the vast range of carcinogens and toxins found in a regular tobacco cigarette. Of course, this is a very controversial topic in which creates a dilemma, some people approve the use of electronic cigarettes as an alternative to tobacco cigarettes. In the other hand thereRead MoreThe Importance of Ethical Management Essays2045 Words   |  9 PagesThe Importance of Ethical Management Managing an organization is not an easy task. Along the road, managers may encounter various issues and therefore have to make difficult decisions while trying to stay a trusted organization. In many managerial situations, maintaining proper ethics in an organization can be considered complicated, yet it is essential not only to avoid legal violations, but also to maintain a reputable business and working environment. I plan to discuss the various hurdlesRead MoreTobacco Advertising Is Illegal but Alcohol Is Not. Is This Hypocritical?3161 Words   |  13 Pagesal., 2010, 502). Today, an average consumer is exposed to hundreds of advertisements every day. It is when these companies attempt to promote a dangerous product that restrictions must be, and have been put in place. For several years, Canada’s regulations on tobacco advertisements have become stricter, while alcohol advertisements are still permitted across multiple mediums. This leads one to question the differe nce between the two substances, and if this notion is in fact hypocritical. The stakeholdersRead MoreA Research On Genetic Engineering2006 Words   |  9 Pagesis the direct manipulation of an organism s genome using biotechnology.† This process can help us eradicate health issues, make our food healthier, and even change our physical appearance. Unfortunately, there are many ethical issues behind the use of genetic engineering. 2. Ethical Concerns Surrounding Genetic Engineering One of the problems surrounding the science of genetics is its ability to cause changes in the ecosystem. Many scientists believe genetics can disrupt the ecosystems to the pointRead MoreA Research And Articles Addressing The Growing Generation Y1841 Words   |  8 Pageswho do not are still skilled employees even with little experience. However, an industry in public or social services is more experienced based. A democratic leadership style would not be effective in public services, especially with the rules, regulations, and laws dictating the boundaries to which the employees must remain. Integration of Behavioral Theories. Organizations continue to suggest more behavioral strategies in the workplace. Behavioral management has started making its way to the forefrontRead More8 Key Element for a Business Model7314 Words   |  30 PagesE-commerce: business. technology. society. E-commerce E commerce Business. Technology. Society gy y Kenneth  C.  Laudon Copyright  © 2011 Pearson Education, Ltd. Chapter 5 Business  Models  for  E†commerce Copyright  © 2007Pearson Education, Ltd. 2011 Pearson Education, Inc. Slide 1-2 E-commerce Business Models Business  model d l Set  of  planned  activities  designed  to  result  in  a   Set of planned activities designed to result in a profit  in  a  marketplace Business  plan Describes  a  firmRead MoreeCommerce Developments and Themes10793 Words   |  44 PagesE-Business Chapter 1 E-commerce Developments and Themes- 2003 More: ï  ® Use of the Internet to conduct commerce ï  ® deepening of e-commerce channel ï  ® Broadband and wireless Internet access ï  ® refined e-commerce business models (→ higher levels of profitability) But at societal level: continued conflict over copyrights, content regulation, taxation, privacy, and Internet fraud and abuse. E-commerce E-business E-commerce involves digitally enabled commercial transactions between and among